Nick Sulzer was an assistant coach of the New York University wrestling team from 2017-2019. He rejoined the staff as a volunteer assistant coach prior to the 2024-25 season.
During the 2025-26 season, NYU reached new heights, setting program records by finishing in fourth place at the NCAA Division III National Championships and producing four All-Americans, the most ever in one season. The foursome included NYU’s second-ever National Champion (Mo Talebi – 197), as well as Alexander Diaz (3rd place – 125), Ty Finn (5th place – 174), and Justin Mayes (8th place – 184).
The ’25–26 squad won a team-record 22 matches (22–4), captured team titles at the University Athletic Association (UAA) Championship, the Ned McGinley Invitational, and the Racich Rumble, in addition to placing second at the NCAA Northeast Regional Championships.
For the second year in a row, NYU earned UAA Coaching Staff of the Year honors.
In 2024-25, NYU’s wrestlers won three team titles, finishing first at the University Athletic Association (UAA) Championship, the Ned McGinley Invitational and the Racich Rumble. The squad posted a 14-6 dual-meet record and finished 29th at the NCAA Division III Championships, while NYU earned UAA Coaching Staff of the Year honors.
Cooper Pontelandolfo became the first wrestler in program history to earn four All-America honors, completing his outstanding career as National Runner-up at 157 pounds. Arguably the most decorated wrestler in team history, Pontelandolfo ended his career by winning the NCAA Region III Championship, both the Ned McGinley and Racich Rumble titles, was named UAA Wrestler of the Year, a National Wrestling Coaches Association (NWCA) Scholar All-American, and earned College Sports Communicators (CSC) Academic All-District honors.
Jacob Venezia, the 133-pound champion at Ned McGinley, also qualified for the NCAA’s and earned NWCA Scholar All-American distinction.
Overall, seven wrestlers won UAA Championships, nine were NWCA Scholar All-Americans and 19 achieved UAA All-Academic honors. Tyler Kadish earned UAA Rookie of the Year honors, while Trent Furman concluded his career with the most falls (60) in program history.
In Sulzer’s first stint with the team, during the 2018-19 season, junior Evan Drill finished fifth in the 141-pound weight class at the NCAA Division III Championships. His outstanding campaign also included being named the University Athletic Association (UAA) Championship Most Outstanding Wrestler and the NYU Male Junior Scholar Athlete of the Year, finishing in second-place at the NCAA Northeast Regionals and being selected National Wrestling Coaches Association (NWCA) All-Academic.
Junior Dylan Dwyer (157 pounds) also qualified for the NCAA’s as NYU finished 30th nationally. The team posted a 15-4 season record and produced fourth-place finishes at the New York State Collegiate Championships, the Citrus Invitational and the Ted Reese Invitational.
Sulzer’s first season in ‘17-18 was also a successful one as the team posted a 12-10 record and won the Ned McGinley Invitational at King’s College. The squad also excelled at the NCAA Northeast Regional Championships, finishing fourth and qualifying four wrestlers for the NCAA Championships, where NYU produced a 19th-place national finish.
Drill (fourth place - 149 pounds) and Raymond Jazikoff (fourth place - 157 pounds) both earned All-America honors after qualifying for the NCAA Championships by winning their respective weight classes at the Northeast Regionals. Sean Lyons (141) and Matt Noble (133) also qualified for nationals.
The roster also featured five UAA All-Association honorees in ’17-‘18: Drill, Jazikoff, Jack Kligerman (184), Jack La Corte (197), and Santino Pelusi (285). In addition, Jazikoff set team records for most wins in a season (48) and career (149).
A graduate of the University of Virginia with a Bachelor of Arts degree in psychology, Sulzer went on to earn a Master in Higher Education Administration degree in 2015, also from UVA.
A four-year member of the Cavaliers’ Division I wrestling team, Sulzer became only the second team member to earn NCAA All-America honors three times, all at 165 pounds. He twice was selected to the NWCA All-Academic Team and earned Virginia’s Top Athletic Scholar Award and its Wrestling Leadership Award in 2015.
His on-mat performances helped lead Virginia to the Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC) Championship in 2015.
Following his career as a student-athlete, Sulzer became an assistant wrestling coach at The Wrestling Factory of Cleveland from 2015-17, where he was responsible for implementing specific practice plans and mentoring young high school wrestlers.
A native of Cleveland, OH, Sulzer currently resides in Manhattan.